Lace up, shoe enthusiasts! We’re about to dive into an epic showdown between two HOKA heavyweights: the Clifton 9 and the Transport X. These runners are turning heads and making waves in the running community, but which one will cross the finish line first in your heart?
Buckle up as we compare these road warriors feature-by-feature, helping you decide which shoe will be your perfect sole mate.
key takeaways:
- The Clifton 9 offers versatility and value at $145, making it ideal for everyday runs and walks. It provides plush cushioning and comes in wide sizes, suitable for various foot types.
- The Transport X, priced at $200, is a performance-oriented shoe with advanced features like a carbon fiber plate and super critical foam. It excels in faster-paced runs and races.
- Both shoes offer different approaches to cushioning and stability. The Clifton 9 provides a balanced, comfortable ride, while the Transport X delivers a more energetic, propulsive feel.
- For all-day standing and walking, the Clifton 9 edges out with its comfortable design. The Transport X, while comfortable, is more suited for dynamic movements and speed work.
- When it comes to specific conditions like plantar fasciitis, the Clifton 9 might be a safer choice for most users due to its plush cushioning and more traditional design.
Comparison Table between Clifton 9 And Transport X:
| Feature | Clifton 9 | Transport X |
|---|---|---|
| Launched In | 2023 | 2023 |
| Stability | Neutral | Neutral |
| Flexibility | Moderate | Moderate |
| Sizing | Regular, Wide | Regular |
| Weight | 8.70 oz | 8.80 oz |
| Cushion | Balanced to Plush | Balanced |
| Outsole | Durabrasion rubber | Low profile sticky rubber |
| Midsole | Compression molded EVA foam | Super critical foam |
| Upper | Engineered knit | Lightweight mesh |
| Retail Price | $145.00 USD | $200.00 USD |
Clifton 9 VS Transport X: FEATURES COMPARISON
1) MATERIAL: outsole, insole, upper sole
The Clifton 9 and Transport X showcase HOKA’s commitment to innovative materials. The Clifton 9 sports a Durabrasion rubber outsole, designed for longevity and grip. Its midsole features compression molded EVA foam, providing a cushy yet responsive ride. The upper is a breathable engineered knit, offering a snug, comfortable fit.
In contrast, the Transport X boasts a low profile sticky rubber outsole, perfect for urban environments. Its midsole uses super critical foam, delivering a bouncy, energetic feel. The upper is constructed with lightweight mesh, ensuring excellent ventilation. Both shoes prioritize comfort and performance, but the Transport X edges ahead in terms of cutting-edge materials.
2) Durability
When it comes to durability, both shoes are built to last, but they shine in different areas. The Clifton 9’s Durabrasion rubber outsole is specifically engineered for extended wear, making it an excellent choice for high-mileage runners. Its compression molded EVA foam midsole maintains its shape and cushioning properties over time, ensuring consistent performance.
The Transport X, while also durable, takes a different approach. Its sticky rubber outsole is designed more for grip than longevity, which might show wear faster on abrasive surfaces.
However, the super critical foam midsole is known for its resilience and ability to maintain its properties over time. The lightweight mesh upper on both shoes is sturdy but may be prone to snagging if used on trails.
3) Fit
Fit is where these shoes diverge significantly. The Clifton 9 offers a more traditional fit with its engineered knit upper that adapts to your foot shape. It also comes in both regular and wide widths, accommodating a broader range of foot types. The gusseted tongue prevents slippage and provides a secure fit.
The Transport X, with its lightweight mesh upper, offers a more streamlined, performance-oriented fit. It’s available only in regular width, which might limit its appeal for those with wider feet.
Both shoes feature HOKA’s signature rocker geometry, but the Transport X’s design feels more aggressive, potentially affecting the overall fit sensation for some users.
4) Cushioning
Cushioning is a hallmark of HOKA shoes, and both models deliver in spades. The Clifton 9 uses compression molded EVA foam in its midsole, providing a plush, comfortable ride that’s become synonymous with the Clifton line. It strikes a balance between softness and responsiveness, making it suitable for both long runs and recovery days.
The Transport X takes cushioning to the next level with its super critical foam midsole. This advanced material offers a more energetic, bouncy feel compared to traditional EVA. The addition of a dual-forked carbon fiber plate in the Transport X provides an extra pop and propulsion, especially noticeable during faster-paced runs.
5) Stability
Both the Clifton 9 and Transport X are classified as neutral shoes, but they approach stability differently. The Clifton 9 features a wider base and HOKA’s signature Meta-Rocker technology, which guides the foot through a more natural gait cycle. This design provides inherent stability without adding extra supportive features.
The Transport X, while also neutral, incorporates a dual-forked carbon fiber plate which adds a level of rigidity and support. This feature, combined with the smooth-riding rocker, offers a unique stability experience. It’s worth noting that the Transport X’s more aggressive rocker geometry might feel less stable to some runners, especially at slower paces.
6) Value For Money
When considering value, we need to look beyond just the price tag. The Clifton 9, priced at $145, offers exceptional value for a daily trainer. It’s versatile enough for most running needs, from easy jogs to longer distances. The durable construction means you’ll likely get many miles out of these shoes before needing a replacement.
The Transport X, at $200, sits in a higher price bracket. However, it justifies this cost with advanced technologies like the carbon fiber plate and super critical foam. It’s a more specialized shoe, excelling in faster-paced runs and races.
If you’re looking for a do-it-all shoe, the Clifton 9 might offer better value. But if you want a high-performance option for speed work and races, the Transport X could be worth the investment.
Clifton 9 VS Transport X: Performance Testing
1) For Walking
When it comes to walking, both shoes offer comfort, but in different ways. The Clifton 9 shines here with its plush compression molded EVA foam midsole. It provides a soft, cushioned feel that’s perfect for long walks or all-day wear. The Meta-Rocker technology helps promote a smooth heel-to-toe transition, which can reduce fatigue during extended walking sessions.
The Transport X, while also comfortable for walking, has a more performance-oriented feel. Its super critical foam midsole and carbon fiber plate provide a springy, energetic sensation that some walkers might find too aggressive for casual strolls. However, if you’re a fast walker or someone who alternates between walking and running, the Transport X could be an excellent choice.
2) For Running
In the running department, both shoes excel, but they cater to different preferences. The Clifton 9 is a versatile workhorse, suitable for a wide range of running activities. Its balanced cushioning makes it comfortable for long, slow runs, while still responsive enough for tempo workouts. The Early Stage Meta-Rocker promotes smooth transitions, making it efficient for longer distances.
The Transport X, with its carbon fiber plate and super critical foam, is built for speed. It excels in faster-paced runs and races, providing excellent energy return and propulsion. The smooth-riding rocker geometry enhances the shoe’s performance at higher speeds.
For runners looking to set personal bests or compete, the Transport X has a clear edge. However, for everyday training runs, some might find the Clifton 9 more comfortable and forgiving.
3) For Standing All Day
When it comes to standing all day, comfort and support are key, and both shoes have their strengths. The Clifton 9, with its plush compression molded EVA foam midsole, provides excellent all-day comfort.
The wider base offers stability, which is crucial for extended periods of standing. The breathable engineered knit upper helps keep feet cool and comfortable throughout the day.
The Transport X, while also comfortable, might be overkill for all-day standing. Its super critical foam midsole and carbon fiber plate are designed more for dynamic movements than static positions.
However, the 360-degree reflectivity could be a bonus for those working in low-light conditions. For most people, the Clifton 9 would be the better choice for all-day standing comfort.
4) For Plantar Fasciitis
For those dealing with plantar fasciitis, both shoes offer features that can help, but in different ways. The Clifton 9’s plush cushioning and Meta-Rocker technology can help reduce strain on the plantar fascia by promoting a more natural foot motion. The option for a wide width can also be beneficial for those needing extra room in the toe box.
The Transport X’s carbon fiber plate provides rigidity that can help support the arch and reduce stress on the plantar fascia. The super critical foam midsole offers responsive cushioning that can absorb impact.
However, the more aggressive rocker geometry might not be suitable for all plantar fasciitis sufferers. Ultimately, the Clifton 9 might be the safer choice for most people with this condition, but individual experiences may vary.
Conclusion: Which Is Better For You
Choosing between the Clifton 9 and Transport X ultimately comes down to your specific needs and preferences. If you’re looking for a versatile, comfortable shoe for everyday runs and walks, the Clifton 9 is hard to beat. Its plush cushioning, durability, and reasonable price point make it an excellent all-rounder.
However, if you’re a performance-oriented runner looking to shave seconds off your PR, the Transport X’s advanced technology and speed-focused design could be your ticket to faster times. Consider your primary use, budget, and personal comfort when making your decision.