The Brooks Caldera 7 and Cascadia 17 represent two of the most popular trail running shoes from Brooks, but they differ in their design and ideal usage. The Caldera 7 delivers an ultra-cushioned yet flexible ride for comfortable long miles, making it best for easier terrain, while the Cascadia 17 provides a protective, stable and responsive feel to attack technical trails.
Read on for a detailed comparison of these two impressive trail shoes to see how they match up in terms of construction, key running features, real-world usage across different scenarios, overall performance benefits, and value to find which model suits your preferences and trail needs better.
Comparison Table between Brooks Caldera 7 And Brooks Cascadia 17:
| Feature | Caldera 7 | Cascadia 17 |
|---|---|---|
| Launched In | 2024 | 2023 |
| Stability | Stable platform | Neutral |
| Flexibility | More flexible than previous versions | Less flexible |
| Sizing | Roomy in toe box | Comfortable fit |
| Weight | Men’s 10.6 oz, Women’s 9.4 oz | Men’s 11.45 oz, Women’s 10 oz |
| Cushioning | DNA Loft v3 (max cushioning) | DNA Loft v2 foam (deep cushioning) |
| Outsole | TrailTack Green rubber, 4mm lugs | TrailTack Green rubber |
| Midsole | DNA Loft v3 | DNA Loft v2 foam |
| Upper | Air mesh upper with overlays | Mesh upper |
| Retail Price | $150 | $140 |
Features Comparison:
Materials:
The Caldera 7 features a soft and bouncy DNA Loft v3 midsole, flexible air mesh upper reinforced with overlays, and a grippy TrailTack Green rubber outsole with 4mm lugs, while the Cascadia 17 uses a DNA Loft v2 foam midsole for deep cushioning, a mesh upper for breathability, and the same TrailTack outsole as the Caldera but without lugs.
The materials of the Caldera focus more on providing softness and flexibility, while the Cascadia focuses on cushioning and protection.
Durability:
The Caldera 7 has an upper that should hold up well to trail debris thanks to protective overlays and technical mesh, while the outsole rubber and DNA Loft foam are also quite durable. Similarly, the Cascadia 17 uses durable TrailTack rubber on the outsole and DNA Loft foam in the midsole.
Both shoes should last for over 300-500 miles for most runners. The Cascadia may have a slight edge thanks to its more protective upper and lack of exposed midsole foam.
Fit:
The Caldera 7 provides a roomy fit in the toe box and secure midfoot lockdown thanks to overlays, making it comfortable for accommodating wider feet or swelling on long runs.
The Cascadia 17 has a balanced comfortable fit in the heel, midfoot and forefoot. For technical terrain, the Cascadia may instill more confidence thanks to its slightly more secure all-around fit.
Cushioning:
With soft, bouncy DNA Loft v3 foam from heel to toe, the Caldera 7 provides a plush comfortable ride that retains cushioning response even over long distances, making it a great choice for easy long runs. The Cascadia 17 utilizes a firmer DNA Loft v2 foam for a very well-cushioned ride with deep cushioning, but doesn’t feel quite as soft as the Caldera 7. For pure cushioned comfort, the Caldera 7 can’t be beat.
Stability:
The Caldera 7 offers adequate midsole stability from its wide platform and TrailTack rubber coverage to support neutral runners while still allowing some natural movement and flex for smoother transitions.
The Cascadia 17 keeps the foot more securely locked in and centered on uneven terrain with its full-length structured DNA Loft midsole, making it suitable for neutral runners as well but with extra medial and lateral support elements.
Value for Money:
With an MSRP of $150, the max-cushioned Caldera 7 punches above its price point in delivering soft comfort for long distances. Similarly, the $140 Cascadia 17 delivers very good well-rounded performance and durability given its cheaper price, making it a great value pick as well. Overall both provide impressive technology and quality for the prices.
Performance Comparison:
Walking:
Both the Caldera 7 and Cascadia 17 deliver ample cushioning comfort for walking, however the DNA Loft v3 foam in the Caldera 7 retains a softer, bouncier feel for longer with each step. The smooth rolloff from heel to toe makes it ideal for longer walks without packing out or losing responsiveness over time.
The Cascadia 17 may actually feel more stable and secure if you need support carrying heavier packs or walking on highly uneven, challenging ground thanks to its structured cushioning and secure upper lockdown.
Running:
Over easier long distance runs or during recovery days, the Caldera 7’s ultra-plush DNA Loft cushioning allows for greater comfort, energy return, and legs that stay fresher while logging high mileage. However, when cranking up to tempo paces or racing over variable, technical trails, the Cascadia 17 begins to shine with its responsive, stable cushioning system and protection that gives confidence to attack rugged terrain and obstacles at faster speeds. Choose the supportive Cascadia 17 for PR attempts on trails rather than recovery.
Standing All Day:
Thanks to the durable DNA Loft v3 foam in the Caldera 7 that maintains its soft, lively cushioning properties even after long periods of time on your feet, it delivers superior comfort ideal for extended standing during long work shifts or travels.
However, the Cascadia 17 with its structured cushioning tuned to provide support also makes for a stable, cushioned platform if you need something to get you through prolonged periods of standing with less fatigue, although initially feels firmer.
Plantar Fasciitis:
Runners who need instant step-in plush comfort from the first wear will benefit most from the Caldera 7’s ultra-cushioned DNA Loft ride that relieves pressure on the plantar fascia. However, for some sufferers who overpronate, the stability elements of the Cascadia 17 can help control excessive foot rotational motion to provide tension relief over time.
Pure cushioning versus controlled stability is the key differentiator – those who need softness immediately can enjoy the Caldera 7 out the box, while it may take some break-in for the Cascadia 17 to reduce pain.
Conclusion:
For runners prioritizing soft, bouncy cushioning and flexibility for comfortable long distance trail runs or recovery days, the Brooks Caldera 7 delivers max comfort from its DNA Loft midsole at an impressive price.
But if you tackle more technical terrain and want stability, protection and responsive cushioning in a durable package, go with the Brooks Cascadia 17 instead. Both the Brooks Caldera 7 VS Brooks Cascadia 17 provide quality trail running performance and features, so base your choice on your specific needs and preferences. The Caldera 7 caters to comfort seekers, while the Cascadia 17 suits those who push the pace over rugged trails.