Lace up, runners! We’re diving into an epic showdown between two HOKA heavyweights: the Clifton 9 and the Cielo X1. These speed demons are ready to hit the pavement, but which one will cross the finish line first in your heart?
Whether you’re chasing PRs or just love a comfy ride, we’re about to break down every detail to help you find your perfect match. Let’s get this race started!
key takeaways:
- The Clifton 9 is a versatile, cushioned daily trainer priced at $145,
while the Cielo X1 is a high-performance racing shoe with a carbon plate,
retailing at $275. - For everyday comfort and durability, the Clifton 9 excels with its plush
cushioning and Durabrasion rubber outsole. The Cielo X1 prioritizes speed
and responsiveness with its PEBA foam and carbon fiber plate. - The Clifton 9 is better suited for walking, standing all day, and managing
plantar fasciitis due to its softer cushioning and comfortable fit. The Cielo X1
is designed primarily for fast-paced running and racing. - Both shoes offer a neutral stability profile, but the Cielo X1 provides a more
locked-down, performance-oriented fit compared to the Clifton 9’s more
accommodating upper. - Choose the Clifton 9 for versatility and all-around comfort in various activities.
Opt for the Cielo X1 if you’re focused on improving race times and don’t mind
the higher price tag for cutting-edge technology.
Comparison Table between Clifton 9 And Cielo X1:
| Feature | Clifton 9 | Cielo X1 |
|---|---|---|
| Launched In | 2023 | 2024 |
| Stability | Neutral | Neutral |
| Flexibility | Moderate | Less flexible (due to carbon plate) |
| Sizing | True to size | True to size |
| Weight | 8.70 oz (Men’s) | 9.30 oz (Unisex) |
| Cushion | Balanced to Plush | Responsive |
| Outsole | Durabrasion rubber | Minimal rubber coverage |
| Midsole | Compression molded EVA foam | Two-layer PEBA foam with carbon fiber plate |
| Upper | Engineered knit | Knit upper and collar |
| Retail Price | $145 | $275 |
Clifton 9 VS Cielo X1: FEATURES COMPARISON
1) Materials: outsole, insole, upper sole
When it comes to materials, these shoes are like distant cousins – related, but oh so different. The Clifton 9 plays it safe with a Durabrasion rubber outsole that’s built to last, perfect for those daily training miles.
Its compression molded EVA foam midsole offers a cushy ride without breaking the bank. Up top, the breathable engineered knit upper hugs your foot like a cozy sock.
The Cielo X1, on the other hand, is the speed freak of the family. It sports a minimal rubber outsole to shave off every possible ounce. The star of the show is its two-layer PEBA midsole with a winged carbon fiber plate – think of it as a springboard for your feet.
The knit upper and collar keeps things light and airy, while an asymmetrical gusseted knit tongue locks your foot down for those blistering paces.
2) Durability
In the durability department, the Clifton 9 is your trusty workhorse. Its Durabrasion rubber outsole is designed to take a beating, mile after mile. The EVA foam midsole might compress a bit over time, but it’ll keep you comfy for hundreds of miles. The engineered knit upper should hold up well, resisting tears and maintaining its shape.
The Cielo X1 is more of a thoroughbred racehorse – built for speed, not necessarily longevity. Its minimal outsole might wear faster, especially if you’re using it for anything other than race day.
The PEBA foam and carbon plate should maintain their pop for a good while, but the ultralight upper might be more prone to wear and tear. This shoe is all about performance over durability.
3) Fit
Slipping into the Clifton 9 feels like coming home. The gusseted tongue prevents slippage, while the engineered knit upper offers a foot-hugging comfort that adapts to your unique shape. It’s available in multiple widths, making it a crowd-pleaser for various foot types. The overall fit is generous enough for comfort but secure enough for confident strides.
The Cielo X1 takes a more performance-oriented approach to fit. Its asymmetrical gusseted knit tongue provides an almost seamless, locked-down feel. The knit upper is less forgiving than the Clifton’s, aiming for a second-skin fit that’s ideal for race day but might feel tight for everyday use. It’s only available in a regular width, so runners with wider feet might find it snug.
4) Cushioning
Prepare for a cushioning contrast! The Clifton 9 is all about that plush life. Its compression molded EVA foam midsole delivers a soft, pillowy ride that’ll keep your feet happy on long runs. The early stage Meta-Rocker design helps smooth out your transitions, making easy miles feel even easier. It’s the kind of shoe that makes you forget you’re wearing shoes at all.
The Cielo X1 takes a different approach, focusing on responsive cushioning. The two-layer PEBA midsole is bouncy and energetic, designed to put a spring in your step. That carbon fiber plate isn’t just for show – it provides a snappy, propulsive feel that’s perfect for picking up the pace. It’s cushioned, sure, but in a way that wants to launch you forward rather than cocoon your feet.
5) Stability
Neither of these shoes is designed for severe overpronators, but they handle stability differently. The Clifton 9 offers a neutral platform with a wide base that provides inherent stability. Its softer cushioning allows your foot to sink in slightly, creating a cradle-like effect. The Meta-Rocker geometry also helps guide your foot through its natural gait cycle.
The Cielo X1 approaches stability from a performance angle. Its carbon fiber plate isn’t just for propulsion – it also adds rigidity and support to the midsole. The winged design of this plate extends to the sides, offering extra stability during quick directional changes. However, the firmer, more responsive cushioning might feel less stable to some runners used to softer shoes.
6) Value For Money
Let’s talk bang for your buck. The Clifton 9, at $145, is a solid value proposition. You’re getting a versatile, comfortable shoe that can handle everything from easy jogs to long runs. Its durability means you’ll be lacing these up for months of consistent training. For a do-it-all daily trainer, the price is right.
The Cielo X1 is playing in a different league at $275. This is a specialized racing shoe, packed with high-end tech like the PEBA foam and carbon plate. If you’re a competitive runner looking for that edge on race day, the price might be justified. For the average runner, though, it’s a significant investment that might be hard to swallow, especially given its narrower range of use.
Clifton 9 VS Cielo X1: Performance Testing
1) For Walking
When it comes to walking, the Clifton 9 struts away with the crown. Its plush cushioning and rocker geometry make every step a pleasure, whether you’re out for a casual stroll or power walking. The breathable upper keeps your feet comfy, and the durable outsole can handle various surfaces. It’s like having pillows strapped to your feet – in a good way!
The Cielo X1, while walkable, feels a bit like overkill. Its responsive cushioning and carbon plate are wasted at walking speeds. The firmer ride might feel less comfortable over long periods of standing or slow-paced walking.
That said, if you’re a fan of a springy feel even when walking, you might enjoy the energy return. Just be prepared for some odd looks if you’re rocking these speed machines for a leisurely park stroll!
2) For Running
Here’s where things get interesting! The Clifton 9 is your trusty training partner. Its cushioned ride and smooth transitions make it perfect for easy runs, long runs, and recovery days.
The Meta-Rocker design helps you roll through your stride effortlessly. It’s not the fastest shoe out there, but it’s comfortable enough to keep you running mile after mile.
The Cielo X1 is built for speed, plain and simple. Its carbon fiber plate and responsive PEBA foam create a propulsive feel that begs you to run faster. It excels in tempo runs, intervals, and race scenarios.
The lightweight design reduces fatigue over longer distances. However, it might feel too aggressive for easy days or recovery runs. This is a shoe that wants to go fast – are you ready to keep up?
3) For Standing All Day
If your job keeps you on your feet, the Clifton 9 is your new best friend. The plush cushioning provides all-day comfort, reducing fatigue in your feet and legs.
The breathable upper prevents that stuffy feeling, and the roomy fit accommodates any swelling that might occur throughout the day. It’s like having an anti-fatigue mat strapped to your feet.
The Cielo X1, while cushioned, isn’t ideal for prolonged standing. Its firmer, more responsive feel might lead to discomfort over time. The snug, performance-oriented fit could feel restrictive during a long shift.
Plus, let’s be honest – wearing a high-end racing shoe for standing around seems a bit like using a race car for grocery runs. It’ll work, but it’s not what it’s made for.
4) For Plantar Fasciitis
For those battling plantar fasciitis, the Clifton 9 offers some solid relief. Its plush cushioning helps absorb impact, reducing stress on the plantar fascia. The Meta-Rocker design promotes a natural foot motion that can alleviate some of the pain associated with this condition. The shoe’s overall comfort and support make it a good choice for keeping your feet happy.
The Cielo X1, while not specifically designed for plantar fasciitis, has some features that might help. The carbon plate provides rigidity that can support the arch, and the responsive cushioning offers good impact protection.
However, its firmer feel might not be as comfortable for sensitive feet. It’s also worth noting that the aggressive design could potentially aggravate symptoms if not used carefully.
Conclusion: Which Is Better For You
Choosing between the Clifton 9 and Cielo X1 boils down to your running goals and budget. The Clifton 9 is your versatile daily trainer – comfortable, durable, and perfect for most of your running needs. It’s the Swiss Army knife of running shoes.
The Cielo X1 is a specialized racing weapon, built for speed and performance. If you’re chasing PRs and don’t mind the price tag, it’s a rocket for your feet. Ultimately, the best shoe is the one that makes you excited to run. Happy trails!