Lace up, running enthusiasts! We’re about to dive into an epic showdown between two HOKA heavyweights: the Clifton 9 and the Skyward X. These shoes are turning heads and setting new standards in the world of running footwear. But which one will cross the finish line first in our comparison? Whether you’re a casual jogger or a seasoned marathoner, buckle up – this head-to-head battle will help you find your perfect running companion.
key takeaways:
- The Clifton 9 offers balanced cushioning and versatility at a mid-range price point, making it suitable for a wide range of running activities and daily use.
- The Skyward X provides maximum cushioning with its PEBA foam and carbon fiber plate, offering a plush ride ideal for long runs and recovery days, but at a higher price.
- Both shoes are neutral in terms of stability, but the Clifton 9 is lighter and more responsive, while the Skyward X offers a more cushioned, “suspended” feel.
- The Clifton 9 may be better for those seeking a balance of comfort and ground feel, while the Skyward X caters to runners who prioritize maximum cushioning and energy return.
- Your choice between the two should depend on your specific needs, running goals, and budget, as both shoes excel in different areas of performance and comfort.
Comparison Table between Clifton 9 And Skyward X:
| Feature | Clifton 9 | Skyward X |
|---|---|---|
| Launched In | 2023 | 2023 |
| Stability | Neutral | Neutral |
| Flexibility | Moderate | Moderate |
| Sizing | 7-16 US (Men’s) | 7-15 US (Men’s) |
| Weight | 8.70 oz | 11.30 oz |
| Cushion | Balanced to Plush | Plush |
| Outsole | Durabrasion rubber | Not specified |
| Midsole | Compression molded EVA foam | PEBA foam with carbon fiber plate |
| Upper | Engineered knit | Flat knit |
| Retail Price | $145 | $225 |
Clifton 9 VS Challenger 7: FEATURES COMPARISON
1) MATERIAL: outsole, insole, upper sole
The Clifton 9 and Skyward X showcase HOKA’s commitment to innovative materials. The Clifton 9 features a Durabrasion rubber outsole, designed for extended longevity and grip.
Its midsole is crafted from compression molded EVA foam, striking a balance between cushioning and responsiveness. The upper is an engineered knit, providing a breathable and adaptive fit.
In contrast, the Skyward X takes a different approach. While its outsole material isn’t specified, it’s likely designed for road running. The midsole is where it truly shines, using PEBA foam – known for its energy return – combined with a carbon fiber plate for added propulsion. The upper is a flat knit design, offering a sock-like fit that molds to your foot.
2) Durability
When it comes to durability, both shoes bring their A-game, but in different ways. The Clifton 9’s Durabrasion rubber outsole is specifically engineered for longevity, promising to withstand many miles of road running. Its EVA foam midsole is known for maintaining its shape and cushioning properties over time.
The Skyward X, while not explicitly touting durability features, uses high-quality materials that suggest good longevity. The PEBA foam midsole is known for its resilience, and the inclusion of a carbon fiber plate adds structural integrity. However, the higher price point of the Skyward X might create higher expectations for durability among users.
3) Fit
Fit is where these shoes take different paths. The Clifton 9 offers a breathable engineered knit upper that adapts to your foot shape, providing a secure yet comfortable fit. It also features a gusseted tongue to prevent slippage and enhance overall fit. The Clifton 9 is available in both regular and wide widths, accommodating a range of foot shapes.
The Skyward X opts for a flat knit upper with zonal engineering, designed to mold to your foot for a sock-like fit. It also incorporates a Deep Active Foot Frame™ that cradles the heel for a secure ride. However, it’s only available in a regular width, which might limit its appeal for those with wider feet.
4) Cushioning
Cushioning is a standout feature for both shoes, but they approach it differently. The Clifton 9 uses compression molded EVA foam in its midsole, providing a balanced cushioning experience that’s responsive yet protective. It’s designed to offer plush comfort without sacrificing energy return, making it suitable for both long runs and everyday use.
The Skyward X takes cushioning to the extreme with its PEBA foam midsole. PEBA is known for its superior energy return and plush feel. Combined with the carbon fiber plate that bows in the middle, it creates what HOKA calls a “suspended feeling.” This setup is designed to provide maximum cushioning and energy return, potentially at the cost of ground feel.
5) Stability
Both the Clifton 9 and Skyward X are classified as neutral shoes, meaning they don’t have additional stability features for overpronators. However, they approach stability differently. The Clifton 9 offers stability through its balanced cushioning and Early Stage Meta-Rocker™ design, which promotes a smoother heel-to-toe transition and natural running gait.
The Skyward X, despite its plush cushioning, incorporates stability features like the Deep Active Foot Frame™ that cradles the heel. It also uses a super critical EVA rocker frame to support the Meta-Rocker™ technology, ensuring a consistently smooth ride despite the high stack height.
6) Value For Money
Value is subjective, but there’s a clear price difference between these models. The Clifton 9, priced at $145, offers excellent value for a daily trainer. It provides HOKA’s signature cushioning, durability, and performance at a mid-range price point. For many runners, it hits the sweet spot of performance and affordability.
The Skyward X, at $225, is a significant investment. It offers cutting-edge technology like the PEBA foam and carbon fiber plate, which may justify the higher price for some runners.
However, its value proposition depends on whether you’ll benefit from its max-cushion, high-energy return design. For casual runners, it might be overkill, but for those seeking the plushest ride possible, it could be worth the splurge.
Clifton 9 VS Skyward X: Performance Testing
1) For Walking
When it comes to walking, both the Clifton 9 and Skyward X offer comfortable experiences, but with different feels. The Clifton 9, with its balanced cushioning and lighter weight (8.70 oz), provides a more nimble and responsive feel for walking. Its Early Stage Meta-Rocker™ design promotes a natural walking gait, making it an excellent choice for all-day comfort.
The Skyward X, while heavier (11.30 oz), offers a supremely plush walking experience. Its PEBA foam and carbon fiber plate combination creates a unique sensation of comfort and energy return with each step.
However, some walkers might find it overly cushioned for casual strolls. The Skyward X might be preferred by those who spend long hours on their feet and prioritize maximum cushioning over a more ground-connected feel.
2) For Running
For running, both shoes excel but cater to different preferences. The Clifton 9 is a versatile daily trainer, suitable for a wide range of running activities. Its balanced cushioning and lightweight design make it ideal for everything from easy recovery runs to tempo workouts. The Early Stage Meta-Rocker™ promotes efficient running form, while the breathable upper keeps feet comfortable during longer runs.
The Skyward X is built for runners who want maximum cushioning and energy return. Its PEBA foam and carbon fiber plate combination provides a unique, propulsive feel that can be beneficial for longer runs or recovery days.
The plush cushioning may help reduce fatigue over long distances. However, some runners might find it less suitable for speed work due to its heavier weight and maximal cushioning, which can reduce ground feel.
3) For Standing All Day
For those who spend long hours on their feet, both shoes offer excellent support, but in different ways. The Clifton 9’s balanced cushioning provides all-day comfort without feeling overly soft.
Its lighter weight (8.70 oz) can help reduce fatigue over long periods of standing. The breathable engineered knit upper helps keep feet cool and comfortable, which is crucial for extended wear.
The Skyward X, with its maximum cushioning, offers a cloud-like standing experience. The PEBA foam provides excellent shock absorption, potentially reducing stress on joints during prolonged standing. The Deep Active Foot Frame™ cradles the foot, providing a sense of stability despite the plush cushioning.
However, its heavier weight (11.30 oz) might be noticeable during extended wear. Some users might find the extreme cushioning too much for all-day standing, preferring a firmer platform.
4) For Plantar Fasciitis
Both shoes offer features that can benefit those with plantar fasciitis, but they approach it differently. The Clifton 9’s balanced cushioning and Early Stage Meta-Rocker™ design can help reduce stress on the plantar fascia by promoting a smoother foot motion.
Its compression molded EVA foam provides adequate shock absorption without being too soft, which can be beneficial for some plantar fasciitis sufferers.
The Skyward X’s maximum cushioning from the PEBA foam midsole could provide excellent shock absorption, potentially alleviating pain associated with plantar fasciitis. The carbon fiber plate might also help reduce strain on the plantar fascia by promoting a more efficient toe-off.
However, some individuals with plantar fasciitis might find the extreme cushioning less stable. It’s worth noting that shoe choice for plantar fasciitis can be highly individual, and what works for one person may not work for another.
Conclusion: Which Is Better For You
Choosing between the Clifton 9 and Skyward X ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences. The Clifton 9 is a versatile, well-cushioned daily trainer that offers excellent value. It’s ideal for those seeking a balance of comfort, performance, and affordability.
The Skyward X, with its premium technology and maximum cushioning, is perfect for runners craving the plushest ride possible and willing to invest in cutting-edge features.
Consider your running goals, budget, and comfort preferences to make the best choice for your feet.